NBA All-Defensive Team Prediction 2012

By Chris Lehman


The all-defensive team is one of the hardest awards to give out. It’s an easy tendency to just look at the steal and block leaders and throw their names on the list, but those stats can be deceptive. A terrible defender can easily get 2 steals a game by anticipating a pass and jumping into the lane. Just the same, someone can give no defensive effort all game and then chase down a fast break and make an impressive block. But a lockdown defender shows up all game and takes it personally when you score on them. Being a Lakers fan, I remember Kobe having to deal with past players  like Bruce Bowen and Doug Christie – those are guys who genuinely enjoyed shutting players down. Looking at the past selections for the team, I’m insulted that Shane Battier has never been named to a 1st team all-defensive team in his career, but only two 2nd team mentions. Here’s this year’s team:

1st Team All-Defensive

Tyson Chandler – He was just named Defensive Player of the Year, so how could he possibly NOT make the list. Yes, he only blocked 1.4 shots per game, but as stated earlier, it’s not always just about the stats. His defensive presence is remarkable. Last year, the Mavericks were the best defensive team in the league and the #3 seed going into the playoffs. Now he’s gone and and just like that the Mavericks aren’t half the team they used to be. This year, the Knicks allowed 94 points per game. In the games that Chandler missed, they gave up 118 to the Spurs who averaged 103, 119 to the Bucks who averaged 99, 112 to the Hawks who averaged 96 and allowed about the average points to the Bobcats (86), but I don’t really consider them a real team.

Kobe Bryant – The guy simply hates being scored on. He always insists on guarding the opposing team’s best player (sometimes switches off with World Peace). Earlier in his career, I think he unfairly won this honor several times. He would play hard for a couple plays at a time, then ease off. But of his 9 first-team mentions, I think he deserves about 5 of them. He’ll guard smaller, quicker players like Rondo and then turn around and push around Carmelo Anthony, who is considered one of the strongest in the league. There’s no such thing as a mismatch for him.

Andre Iguodala – The 76ers have the 3rd best scoring defense in the league. Iguodala has a lot to do with that. He’s fast and strong enough to matchup with just about any player on the court. Now that he has a couple other guys around him who can score, the pressure isn’t as heavy on him to score all the points so he can really lock down on the defensive end. I look for him to be on this list for years to come.

Iman Shumpert – As a rookie, he has already established himself on the defensive end. On a team with so much offensive firepower, it’s easy to completely ignore the defense. But with Anthony and Stoudemire pretty much useless on that end of the ball, it is necessary to have someone who can really lock down on the wing – and that’s what Shumpert is there to do. Unfortunately, he injured his ACL and to my knowledge will miss the playoffs. This will really hurt their chances of being able to beat the Heat.

Serge Ibaka – This is a no-brainer. Lieutenant Serge is a one man wrecking crew. It seems like he blocks everything that comes through the paint. He was the missing piece to the Thunder’s success. He is the reason behind my strong belief that OKC will win it all this year. He is averaging nearly 4 blocks a game. That’s almost 1.5 higher than Javale McGee in 2nd. Long story short, don’t try to dunk on him. It won’t end well.

2nd Team All-Defensive

DeAndre Jordan – His game is similar to Tyson Chandler’s, but not on the same level. He’ll very rarely score more than 10 points in a game, but there’s a very good chance he’ll grab 10 rebounds and anywhere up to 6 blocks.

Aaron Afflalo – He’s quietly a very good player. Great three point shooter and lock down defender. Similar to Bruce Bowen, but more athletic.

Shane Battier – The man always does his job. The best at the hand-in-your-face-while-trying-to-shoot style. Wish I could have him on my 1st team.

Thabo Sefolosha – The Thunder are one of, if not THE, best scoring team in the league. That’s mainly because of three guys. The others all have defined roles. Sefolosha knows his. He guards the best perimeter player and he does it very well.

Greg Stiemsma – Averages 1.5 blocks in under 14 minutes.



  1. I’m glad that someone had the guts to not put LeBron on the NBA All Defensive 1st team….
    LeBron is simply an overrated defender and if you just key in on him the entire game you will see how he is a pretty bad one on one defender, gets blown by consistently, and plays hard some possessions and then takes many off…
    But people don’t see that; they just see the chasedown block every 5 games or him getting into the passing lanes every now and then… But whenever he plays bad ‘D’ no one makes mention of it….

    I’ll give one thing to ‘Bron…. He is a very versatile defender and he can guard PGs to PFs; but if someone was his size and speed…. You should be able to do that…

    For example…. But Kobe’s defensive tenacity, agility and footwork in LeBron’s body type…. Kobe would go down as the greatest perimeter defender ever by far….

    Kobe even at his advanced age has shut down Russell Westbrook, Rajon Rondo, Dwyane Wade(multiple times), and whenever he guards LeBron he makes it real tough for him to score even tho LBJ weighs about 55 more lbs than Bryant…
    And no one forgets when Bryant took the challenge of guarding Melo in the 2009 WCF; who can basically score at will on any defender because of his strength and one on one moves… And Bryant at times would bully Melo off the post even tho Melo has about a 30lb difference over Bryant

    • Right? I don’t consider someone making one nice block a game the league’s best small forward defender. Someone posted a video on my Facebook of LeBron fronting Pau Gasol in the post twice and that was his argument for why he should be on it. Yeah, it’s a nice play, but you gotta do that every play for the whole game.
      I appreciate the comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s